Gapers Block has ceased publication.

Gapers Block published from April 22, 2003 to Jan. 1, 2016. The site will remain up in archive form. Please visit Third Coast Review, a new site by several GB alumni.
 Thank you for your readership and contributions. 


Monday, June 24

Gapers Block

Gapers Block on Facebook Gapers Block on Flickr Gapers Block on Twitter The Gapers Block Tumblr


May 10, 2004 marked the 10th anniversary of the day serial killer John Wayne Gacy, Jr. was put to death in Joliet, Illinois. I'd all but forgotten about him. I wouldn't even be mentioning the event were it not for the fact that I was at the Stateville Correctional Center the night Mr. Gacy was executed.


John Gacy was a contractor as well as a part-time artist and entertainer. As Pogo the Clown he appeared at area hospitals and festivals for years, much to the delight of children and families alike.

Unfortunately, he was also a psychopath with a penchant for killing young men. Gacy was one of the most notorious serial killers in the U.S., if not the world. From 1972 to 1978 he murdered 33 young boys and buried them in the crawl space of his home in suburban Chicago.

So why on Earth would I be on the scene on his final day of life? I figured I owed it to the guy. He played an integral part in my life for nearly 20 years.

John Gacy may have been the first "famous person" whose name I ever knew. Well actually, he was the second. Actor John Wayne was the first. I only remembered John Wayne Gacy because of the similar name.

I was born in 1970. By the time I was 5 or 6, word had started to spread about a possible mass murderer in our midst. Stories of the deaths were on television and in the conversations around me. When police reports surfaced about primary suspect, John Wayne Gacy, his name became as famous as that of Ronald McDonald, Kermit the Frog, Captain Kangaroo, or any other name a kid would recognize. Without actually knowing what a horrible man this Gacy fellow was, I knew his name.

By the time he was arrested in the late '70s I knew who he was. He was a guy who lived near where my Dad taught school. He was a neighbor of some friends of mine. He was that murderer I'd heard about on TV. Everyone was glad to hear of his capture. His 33 life sentences and 12 death sentences made no sense to me. How many lives or deaths could one guy serve in jail? But they made everyone feel at ease, knowing we'd never hear from him again. Of course we were wrong.

Gacy stories sold newspapers and got TV ratings! I can recall front page stories in the Sun Times about John Gacy's love letters to his pen-pal. I remember seeing interview after interview with the man on TV. For the remaining years of his life, when he sneezed, a camera crew was there to capture the moment.

At age 18, 10 years after Gacy had confessed to the crimes, I went to Ringling Bros. and Barnum and Bailey Clown College. There, I'd learned about Gacy's effect on the clowning world. Everyone who wasn't already afraid of clowns was definitely afraid of them after Gacy. When asked the question, "Wasn't that John Gacy a clown?" I'd frequently have to explain that as a practice, I didn't kill people. My friends, John Wayne Gacy was a tough act to follow!

My brief time as a clown was fraught with Gacy coincidences. Forget the fact I lived just a few miles from the site where all those remains were buried. Forget the fact I was also a clown. Gacy was following me in ways I'd never imagined possible.

One day in 1990, I went to my local hardware store next to a strip mall that housed the Angel Town Day Care Center to make copies of a promotional flier. The store owner came by to make small talk. Noticing the clown photo on the flier he said, "I can't be around clowns after that Gacy thing." I explained that I get comments like that a lot. He followed with, "You don't understand. I knew him. He built the strip mall next door. He'd come in here for coffee and supplies all the time." I did find a bit of irony in the fact that a notorious serial killer built a daycare center named Angel Town, but didn't comment. We chatted about Pogo and his antics. The shopkeeper suggested I get out of clowning. The next two eerie coincidences reinforced his recommendation.

On two separate occasions, a corporate event and a festival, I found out that I was the first clown they'd hired since "the last guy." I asked who the last guy was, figuring it was someone who'd showed up late or done some other offensive thing that would turn a group against hiring a similar act. Of course, "the last guy" was John Gacy himself. One guy actually showed me pictures of Gacy working the event on the very same stage I was to perform. "We checked you out real good before deciding to hire you," the client confessed. Did I mention that he was a tough act to follow? I began to give some serious thought to leaving behind my oversized shoes and make-up forever.

By 1994, Pogo had come to the end of his rope. All appeals and legal maneuvers had been exhausted and he was all set to be put to death by lethal injection in Joliet. Of course, the media couldn't stop Gacy Fever. On May 9 every news story was about Gacy's final hours. My roommate, Mike, and I watched some TV coverage from the prison. The angle being examined was the death penalty itself. One reporter on the scene commented on how relatively few death penalty protestors and supporters were in attendance. There were a few folks marching at the prison and a few folks who were very glad that this day had finally come.

With about three hours before zero hour, my roommate made a brilliant suggestion. Now I won't pretend that alcohol had nothing to do with his idea. It did. We had already had a few beers to celebrate the events of the day when my roommate said, "We should go."

"Go? To the prison?" I asked.

"Let's go," he said. "Joliet is only an hour away." I thought it would be nothing if not bizarrely entertaining, so we jumped in the car and went to Joliet, having no idea what we'd do when we got there.


During the car ride I thought about how much Gacy knowledge I'd been force fed over the years. I reflected about the odd times his life crossed paths with my own. I came to the conclusion that I was glad to see him go and I needed to be there. Plus, I was very happy to hear that Mike would drive.

We didn't even know exactly where the prison was but we figured we were getting very close when we started seeing signs that read, "DO NOT PICK UP HITCHHIKERS." When we saw the mammoth line of cars up and down Route 53 in Joliet we figured we'd found our target. Apparently there were quite a few folks who'd decided to make this ridiculous trek.

We made the walk to the prison and entered the gates. We were searched and frisked by state police and led into the courtyard area. The officers were not allowed to make any comments as to their personal feelings about the event. They were only allowed to tell us to follow the orange fencing.

The orange plastic fencing that was erected for the event took us to a fork in the path, where a state trooper stood. He told us the path to the right would lead to protestors and the path to the left was for supporters. I felt like a family member at the strangest wedding in history. We chose left. Sure enough, there was another fence diving "Us" from "Them."

We all watched the protestors quietly holding a candlelight vigil and saying prayers for Gacy's soul. What was oddly touching was that the folks for Gacy dying did not make any efforts to interfere with those who were against the death penalty. Everyone respected everyone else's points of view. Of course, it didn't take long before "Us" greatly outnumbered "Them."

Anyone with any sense of fun was on our side. There was a real party atmosphere in our camp; it was unlike anything I'd ever seen. People were mixing, shaking hands and meeting one another, united by the impending death of Gacy. Mike even bumped into people he knew. People created signs and statues for the occasion. There was even a guy selling t-shirts commemorating the event -- I would have bought one if they weren't $40 a pop. Games of hackey sack broke out and people everywhere were singing songs, mugging for the cameras and chanting, "Take Down the Clown!" Aside from the lack of drugs or alcohol, it was not unlike a concert festival. Gacypalooza, LIVE from Stateville Prison!

Mike and I went there to find something unusual, and indeed we found it. When the crowd got too large for comfort, we decided to head back to the car. By then the crowd of protestors had grown considerably, but still no one disturbed their protest. I overheard one of the troopers say the head count had reached 2,400. Some time before we made it to the car we heard an loud, sustained cheer from the crowd. We figured it was well past midnight and the deed must be done.

While walking back to the car we noticed a rather large number of tailgate parties taking place on the roadside. There was music, there were TVs powered by car batteries, and bratwursts were being cooked on portable grills. We wanted in on the fun.

The day before Mike and I had been grilling at a park. As luck would have it we never took the grill and ice-filled cooler out of his trunk. There were two cheese-filled brats and two ice cold bottles of Coke waiting for us. We fired up the grill and enjoyed our feast. Of course the whole thing needed something else: beer! We weren't going to go find a store and return -- after all, that would be just silly -- so we went to a neighboring pick-up truck and asked if they had any beer to sell. I had exactly two dollars on me and I figured that could buy at least one beer. The guy looked at us and asked, "Are you happy to see Gacy go on this day?" We told him we were indeed pleased to see our hometown murderer put to death, and he smiled. "I couldn't think of charging you for a beer in that case." We were given two cans of Hamm's, and while I would never consider drinking such a horrible beer any other day, it seemed a delicious and fitting beverage. My dinner with Gacy was complete.

John Wayne Gacy continues to be a part of my life; I now relay the more comical aspects of the Gacy/Martello coincidences in my comedy act. I suppose he'll never really go away. Had I not heard about the 10th anniversary of his execution on the radio I wouldn't have thought about where I was 10 years ago. With that day came the end of a sordid and macabre tale, and while I can't expect the victims to look upon the anniversary with any humor, I can hope that the families of the victims, as well as Gacy's own family, were able to find some closure.


About the Author(s)

Andy Martello is a comedian, juggler and freelance writer living in the Chicagoland area. More information about Andy and his writing can be found at and his new blog,

GB store

Recently on Detour

A Tragic Day in Chicago
While most people see the weekend after Thanksgiving as a time to begin preparations for the December holiday season, this time of year is a painful reminder to some as the anniversary of one of Chicago's deadliest fires. Ninety-two students...

The Social Life of Our Urban Spaces
"Placemaking" comes to Chicago

Don't '&' Me, OK?
The ampersand gets Wenner thinking about the distinction between race and ethnicity.

Photo Essay: Transitions
Rearview contributers interpret the theme "Transitions."

People from the Rearview Archive
Gapers Block digs into the Rearview archive in search of portraits.

View the complete archive

GB Store

GB Buttons $1.50

GB T-Shirt $12

I ✶ Chi T-Shirts $15